Who will most likely feel highly engaged and be more productive? Why will this person be m

Four employees received feedback from their managers. Jose was told what he did wrong and was given a warning. Jolette was told that she has been too shy in team meetings and is not speaking enough. Richard was told that his unique skill of analysis has been very valuable to the team. Gloria was told about some errors she made on the reports the team produced. Who will most likely feel highly engaged and be more productive? Why will this person be more engaged and productive? What can be done through feedback to help the other team members be more engaged and productive?